Skip to content

Risk Academy, led by the Nexus Consortium · Governance, Policy and International Affairs · Department of Peace, Conflict and Security

Defence, deterrence and the hybrid threats below the threshold of war

સુરક્ષા, સંરક્ષણ અને મિશ્ર ખતરા

Security risk now runs through infrastructure, information and trade as much as through armed forces.

Map security, defence and hybrid threats on a real placeSee the courses

Illustrative: packages on a board with routed traces carrying clocked signals, or a data hall of racks and their status lights

01વ્યાપ

What the discipline covers

The subtopics its courses and labs teach.

અભ્યાસક્રમો
In preparation
સ્તરો
In development
પ્રયોગશાળાઓ
In development
  • Security studies and threat assessment
  • Hybrid threats and grey-zone activity
  • Sabotage of critical infrastructure and subsea assets
  • Economic coercion and weaponised interdependence
  • Civil preparedness and total defence
  • Deterrence and escalation
  • Arms control and non-proliferation
  • Defence and security in space and cyberspace
  • Societal resilience to foreign interference

02નકશા

Build a twin of any place

Search any place or open the world; the layers and generators follow security, defence and hybrid threats on the planet map, the globe and in 3D.

The Horn of Africa and the Nile basin states: a flat plan of the faculty twin. 13 countries; First-level divisions, geoBoundaries gbOpen with a licence gate per boundary: read live when the 3D twin opens; Natural events, NASA EONET: read live when the 3D twin opens. Graticule every five degrees; countries (natural earth 1:110m) as outlines.
The Horn of Africa and the Nile basin states, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Sudan, South Sudan, Eritrea, Djibouti, Uganda and neighbours. Flat map of the same data: the 13 countries on a graticule and the numbers below. The globe opens on devices that can draw it, once its code has been checked; the live events and divisions load in the globe on request, each with its data date.
  • 13 countries
  • First-level divisions, geoBoundaries gbOpen with a licence gate per boundary: read live when the 3D twin opens
  • Natural events, NASA EONET: read live when the 3D twin opens
Credits and dates per layer are listed under the stage. Countries are raised on the globe for legibility.

Drag to turn the globe, Ctrl with the wheel to zoom. Keyboard: arrows turn, + and – zoom, 0 resets, V steps through the views, Escape clears.

Flat map of the same data: the 13 countries on a graticule and the numbers below. The globe opens on devices that can draw it, once its code has been checked; the live events and divisions load in the globe on request, each with its data date.

The boundaries, names and designations shown do not imply any judgement on the legal status of any territory, or any endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. Countries: Natural Earth (public domain).

03The subject

The subject, methods and measures and debates and bodies

The discipline

The field and its scope

For defence and civil preparedness planners, infrastructure operators, security analysts and policy advisers who need to assess hybrid threats, deterrence and societal resilience as risk problems.

This field treats national and international security as a risk discipline. It covers threat assessment and defence planning, deterrence and escalation, arms control and non-proliferation, and the hybrid threats that combine sabotage, cyber attack, disinformation, economic coercion and the use of proxies below the threshold of declared war. It draws on strategic studies, international relations, intelligence analysis, engineering of critical infrastructure and the practice of civil preparedness and total defence in states such as Finland and Sweden, and it increasingly concerns space and cyberspace as domains in their own right.

The analytic foundations are the security dilemma described by Jervis (1978), deterrence theory from Schelling to Morgan, and the recent work on grey-zone activity and weaponised interdependence. Practice is organised around national security strategies and threat assessments, NATO's resilience commitments under Article 3 of the Washington Treaty, the European Union's framework on countering hybrid threats, the Hybrid Centre of Excellence in Helsinki, and the civil-military arrangements that protect energy, communications, subsea cables and supply chains. The field serves ministries of defence and interior, infrastructure operators, intelligence and resilience agencies, and the organisations whose assets and staff are now targets. Its central difficulty is attribution and response below the threshold of armed attack.

Measures

Quantities and units

QuantityUnit or scaleWhat to know
Military expenditureconstant United States dollars per year, and per cent of GDPThe Stockholm International Peace Research Institute estimated world military expenditure at 2,718 billion dollars in 2024, a 9.4 per cent real increase; estimates for several states rely on partial budgets and the definitional boundary with internal security varies.
Alliance spending benchmarkper cent of GDPNATO members agreed a 2 per cent guideline in 2014 and in 2025 committed to 5 per cent by 2035, split between core defence and related investment; what counts as related investment is defined by the allies and is not comparable across them.
Attributed state-linked cyber operationscount per year, by target sectorCompiled from public attributions by governments and vendors in databases such as the European Repository of Cyber Incidents; attribution is selective and political, so counts measure what was disclosed.
Infrastructure incident frequencyincidents per year on subsea cables, pipelines and energy networks, with cause classificationOperators and bodies such as the International Cable Protection Committee record faults; most are accidental, and the share attributed to sabotage depends on investigation that is often inconclusive.
Civil preparedness reservesdays of supply, or share of households with stated readinessGovernments such as Sweden and Finland publish guidance on household readiness and track emergency stocks of fuel, food and medicines; survey measures of readiness are self-reported.

પદ્ધતિઓ

Methods and their limits

Each method is listed with what it assumes and where it fails.

પદ્ધતિAssumesFails when
Threat assessmentThat an adversary's capability and intent can be estimated from intelligence and open sources, and combined with vulnerability to rank threats for planning.When intent is inferred from capability alone, when assessments are shaped by the budgets they justify, or when the adversary changes faster than the assessment cycle.
Deterrence analysisThat an adversary calculates costs and benefits and can be dissuaded by a credible threat of denial or punishment communicated clearly.Below the threshold where responses are credible, against actors who misperceive signals or value the stakes differently, and when the defender's own commitment is doubted; Morgan (2003) sets out the limits.
Hybrid threat mappingThat instruments across domains, from cyber intrusion to energy coercion and information operations, can be catalogued, attributed and read as a coordinated campaign.When coordination is assumed from coincidence, when attribution rests on classified evidence that cannot be shared, or when the frame expands until every adverse event is hybrid.
Critical infrastructure dependency analysisThat interdependencies among energy, communications, transport, finance and water can be modelled so that the cascading effects of an attack are anticipated and the most critical nodes protected.When operators do not share topology, when the model omits cross-border links, or when protection of mapped nodes shifts attack to unmapped ones.
Exercises and war-gamingThat structured play of a scenario with real decision makers reveals gaps in authority, communication and capability that documents do not.When the scenario is scripted to succeed, when findings are not tracked to remedy, or when adversary play is unrealistic.

Debates

What the field debates

Is hybrid warfare a new category or an old practice renamed
Those who treat it as new point to the combination of cyber, information and economic instruments at scale and to doctrines that integrate them, citing Hoffman's (2007) framing and recent sabotage cases. Galeotti (2019) and others argue that subversion, proxies and coercion are as old as statecraft, that the label flatters adversaries with coherence they lack, and that it blurs the thresholds on which law and deterrence depend.
Deterrence below the threshold
One position holds that deterrence by denial, through resilience and attribution, can work against grey-zone activity and that cumulative responses can be made credible. Rid (2012) and sceptics argue that cyber and hybrid operations are designed to remain below response thresholds, that deterrence theory does not transfer, and that defence and resilience rather than deterrence are the realistic aims. Evidence from attributed campaigns is read both ways.
Economic interdependence: stabiliser or vulnerability
Liberal arguments hold that trade and financial ties raise the cost of conflict and remain a restraint. Farrell and Newman (2019) and the economic security literature argue that asymmetric interdependence gives hub states coercive leverage and that dependencies in energy, semiconductors and payments are now attack surfaces. Both cite the sanctions and energy record since 2022.

Bodies and data

Bodies that set practice, and the data they publish

Bodies and standards are named so learners can find and apply their published work; the Academy teaches their use and links to the publisher, and no affiliation is implied.

BodyRole in the field
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)Collective defence alliance whose Article 3 resilience commitments and seven baseline requirements shape national civil preparedness among allies.
European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats (Hybrid CoE)Helsinki-based centre for participating states, the EU and NATO that produces analysis, training and exercises on hybrid threats.
European Union (External Action Service and Commission)Maintains the Joint Framework on countering hybrid threats (2016) and the Critical Entities Resilience and NIS2 directives that set resilience duties for operators.
National security and civil preparedness agenciesBodies such as the Swedish Civil Contingencies Agency and the Finnish Security Committee that run total defence planning and public guidance.
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI)Independent institute whose databases on military expenditure, arms transfers and nuclear forces are the reference series for the field.
International Atomic Energy Agency and the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical WeaponsVerification bodies for the nuclear non-proliferation and chemical weapons regimes.
DatasetSteward
SIPRI Military Expenditure DatabaseStockholm International Peace Research Institute
European Repository of Cyber IncidentsEuRepoC consortium
UN Treaty Collection (disarmament treaties)United Nations Office of Legal Affairs
Digital Society Project expert survey data (179 countries, 2000 to 2025)Digital Society Project, with the Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Institute

04પદ્ધતિ

From an outage to an uncovered day: civil preparedness as days of supply against a disruption

A hybrid attack on infrastructure is felt as an outage of some length; households and systems hold a stock measured in days of supply; the days the outage runs beyond the stock are the uncovered days a civil preparedness policy exists to reduce.

Sources: NATO, Resilience, civil preparedness and Article 3 (2024); European Commission and High Representative, Joint Framework on countering hybrid threats: a European Union response, JOIN(2016) 18 (2016); Wigell, Hybrid interference as a wedge strategy: a theory of external interference in liberal democracy (2019); Rid, Cyber War Will Not Take Place (2012); Jervis, Cooperation under the Security Dilemma (1978).

05At a glance

At a glance, hub and courses

3D ગ્રાફ

શાસન, નીતિ અને આંતરરાષ્ટ્રીય બાબતો ફેકલ્ટી

299 nodes1,837 relations9 views

Explore the 3D graph: Faculty of Governance, Policy and International Affairs

06કન્સોલ

How Security, defence and hybrid threats is taught, as a process you can run

Press Play to run this process from this page's own data.

સુરક્ષા, સંરક્ષણ અને મિશ્ર ખતરા

How Security, defence and hybrid threats is taught

5 subjects in scope, 3 key terms, courses in development, 1 lab, in the Peace, Conflict and Security department of Governance, Policy and International Affairs: from the scope to the method and its terms, the courses that teach it, the labs on the twin, the assessment and the record.

  1. 01 Scope

    1. 01

      Security studies and…

      Start · the discipline

      Security studies and threat assessment

    2. 02

      Hybrid threats and…

      Start · the discipline

      Hybrid threats and grey-zone activity

    3. 03

      Sabotage of critical…

      Start · the discipline

      Sabotage of critical infrastructure and subsea assets

    4. 04

      Economic coercion and…

      Start · the discipline

      Economic coercion and weaponised interdependence

    5. 05

      Civil preparedness and…

      Start · the discipline

      Civil preparedness and total defence

  2. 02 Method and terms

    1. 06

      From an outage to an…

      Model · the learner

      A hybrid attack on infrastructure is felt as an outage of some length; households and systems hold a stock measured in days of supply; the…

    2. 07

      Hybrid threat

      Record · the discipline

      Coordinated use of military and non-military means, such as sabotage, cyber attacks and disinformation, below the threshold of open war.

    3. 09

      Grey zone

      Record · the discipline

      Competition between states that stays below the threshold that would trigger a conventional military response.

    4. 11

      Total defence

      Record · the discipline

      A national approach in which civil society, business and government prepare alongside the armed forces.

  3. 04 Labs

    1. 08

      ટ્વિન

      Exercise · the learner, on the faculty twin

      The method runs on the faculty twin and the admitted map layers.

  4. 05 Assess

    1. 10

      Module checks

      Gate · the course

      Each module ends with a short check against its outcomes.

    2. 12

      Assessed work

      Decision · the learner

      The assessed work that closes a course: a lab record, a case memo or an assignment, reviewed against the rubric.

  5. 06 Record

    1. 13

      પૂર્ણતા રેકોર્ડ

      Outcome · the learner

      The record stacks into the discipline achievement.

    2. 14

      Discipline achievement

      Record · the Academy

      The discipline achievement follows the discipline rule, read from the records.

Security, defence and hybrid threats · Peace, Conflict and Security An outline of how the work is designed to run; it does not report the status of any decision or record.

07Practice

Practice, learning and connections

Technology in this area

How technology helps and what risk it brings

AspectIn this area
Technology that helpsForesight tools and regulatory sandboxes.
Risk technology createsThreats to information integrity, and AI in public decisions.
  • RAS-421 Strategic Foresight and Horizon Scanning In development
  • RAS-422 Responsible Innovation and Technology Assessment In development
  • RAT-248 Information Integrity: Analysis and Response In development
  • RAT-260 AI Assurance, Audit and Conformity Assessment In development

Achievements

Achievements in this discipline

  1. Course achievements

    One for each course with this as its primary discipline, earned when you pass the course's assessed activities.

  2. Department: Peace, Conflict and Security

    Earn two discipline achievements in the Department of Peace, Conflict and Security. In development.

An achievement is a record of the learning completed and assessed here. How recognition works.

Where this is practised

Where the subject is practised

A field platform page on this subject is in development.

Practised in

The three Foundry systems where it is practised

Foundry system pages describe what each system and its rooms are designed to do; the courses teach the methods these systems apply.

Across the ecosystem

Across the ecosystem

The science, platforms and standards this discipline draws on and contributes to across the ecosystem.

Foundations in the STEM Commons

  • The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI Canada)Policy, institutional and decision sciencePolicy, institutional and decision science studies how public decisions are made, implemented and evaluated.
  • Cybersecurity and cryptographyCybersecurity and cryptography protect information systems and data from unauthorised access, disruption and manipulation.
  • Game theory and mechanism designGame theory and mechanism design study strategic interaction among decision makers and the design of rules that lead to desired outcomes.

Pages of the ecosystem, cited so learners can follow the field into research, platforms, standards and national practice.

08ભાગ લો

Take part in Governance, Policy and International Affairs

તમે કોણ છો ત્યાંથી શરૂ કરો.

Routes

  • માર્ગ

    રાષ્ટ્રીય સંસ્થાઓ

    Ministries, statistics offices and agencies: a national desk and chapter, and a seat in the working groups. National chapters

  • માર્ગ

    Sectors and professions

    Operators, regulators, banks, insurers and professional bodies whose work touches governance, policy and international affairs. For organisations

  • માર્ગ

    શિક્ષણ

    Courses and practice, with a record of every course completed. Free to study. Open learning

  • માર્ગ

    ધોરણો

    Draft, review and adopt the methods and data standards with the working groups. Working groups

  • માર્ગ

    Communities and research

    Universities, civil society and individual experts: projects, data and review. Write to the Academy

Open calls

Open callSeeksCloses
Founding call for experts to the working groups CALL-FOUNDING-EXPERTSexpert, editor, chair2026-12-15
Open nomination for the three independent expert seats of the Global Standards Council CALL-GSC-INDપરિષદ-સભ્ય2026-12-01
Nominations of interim regional members (applies only if the transitional provision is decided) CALL-GSC-REGપરિષદ-સભ્ય2026-12-15
Review of the wave-1 risk core outlines (C1, C2, C3, C4, C8, C10, C11) CALL-REVIEW-WAVE1contributor2027-01-31
જોખમ વિજ્ઞાનનાં મુખ્ય ધોરણો માટે નિષ્ણાતો: અનિશ્ચિતતા અને પુરાવા ગ્રેડિંગ, માપક્રમો, સંરચિત નિષ્ણાત નિર્ણય, સહનશીલતા, ચરમસીમાઓ અને સંયુક્ત ઘટનાઓ, આપત્તિજનક અને અસ્તિત્વગત જોખમ, નીતિશાસ્ત્ર અને સમાનતા, એકમો અને માપન (NRS-C17 થી NRS-C24) CALL-CORE-SCIENCEexpert, editor, chair2027-01-31
Independent reviewers for the families of the hazard atlas, three from at least two regions for each family (NHS2-R19), priority families first CALL-ATLAS-REVIEWનિષ્ણાત2027-03-31
વચગાળાની અગ્રણી સલામતી સમીક્ષા પેનલના સભ્યો અને રેડ-ટીમ સમીક્ષકો (જૈવ સલામતી અને જૈવ સુરક્ષા, AI સલામતી અને સુરક્ષા, મહત્વપૂર્ણ માળખાગત સુરક્ષા); અરજીઓ ગુપ્ત રીતે સંભાળાય છે CALL-FRONTIER-SAFETY-REVIEWનિષ્ણાત2026-11-30
આવશ્યકતા રજિસ્ટર, NHS-2 મશીન પ્રતિનિધિત્વ, અનુરૂપતા પરીક્ષણ સમૂહો અને અનુરૂપતા મૂલ્યાંકન યોજના માટે ઓન્ટોલોજી, માપવિજ્ઞાન, સોફ્ટવેર ચકાસણી અને અનુરૂપતા મૂલ્યાંકનના નિષ્ણાતો CALL-CONFORMANCE-ONTOLOGYexpert, editor2027-01-31

Calls past their closing date are hidden automatically. Every call, proposal and route: open areas and calls.

Cells and CERTs

  1. Gather the cell

    Bring together three to seven people with complementary skills: data, field practice, policy and communication.

  2. Register it

    Write to the team with the cell's name, members, area and region. You receive a reference and a contact. Write to the Academy

  3. Choose a charter

    Pick one focus: research and evidence, data and maps, standards review, or community preparedness.

  4. Learn together

    Follow shared study paths at Risk Academy, with practice and a record of every course completed. Hazards and resilience

  5. Lead and report

    Hold regular sessions. Publish what the cell learns through Reports. Bring findings to the working groups. Working groups

  • Specialise as a Community Emergency Response Team (CERT)

    A CERT prepares its neighbourhood for the hazards it faces. It builds a local hazard profile from this site's map. It trains in household and street preparedness. It learns first aid and light search through recognised local providers, and it runs drills. A CERT works alongside the local emergency services and follows their direction. It never replaces them and is not an emergency service.

સૂચકાંક

What a national team or a local community can do on The Global Risks Index (NXS-GRX) today.

  • NXS-GRX

    Your country's profile

    Open risk profiles for 195 countries, with sources and licences on every value. Open the Index

  • NXS-GRX

    Correct or reply

    Correct a value or reply for your country. The change is logged with its effect. Open the Index

  • NXS-GRX

    Offer data

    Offer a dataset. It enters through the licence gate, with your credit. Open the Index

  • NXS-GRX

    Use the open data

    Layers, profiles and tiles through the open API. Open the Index

09References

Core references and where to begin

Start with Jervis, then Morgan, then Hoffman.

  1. Jervis, R., Cooperation under the Security Dilemma (1978). DOI
  2. Morgan, P. M., Deterrence Now (2003). DOI
  3. Hoffman, F. G., Conflict in the 21st Century: The Rise of Hybrid Wars (2007). potomacinstitute.org
  4. Galeotti, M., The mythical Gerasimov Doctrine and the language of threat (2019). DOI
  5. Wigell, M., Hybrid interference as a wedge strategy: a theory of external interference in liberal democracy (2019). DOI
  6. Rid, T., Cyber War Will Not Take Place (2012). DOI
  7. Farrell, H. and Newman, A. L., Weaponized Interdependence: How Global Economic Networks Shape State Coercion (2019). DOI
  8. European Commission and High Representative, Joint Framework on countering hybrid threats: a European Union response (JOIN(2016) 18) (2016). eur-lex.europa.eu
  9. NATO, Resilience, civil preparedness and Article 3 (2024). nato.int

10પ્રશ્નો

પ્રશ્નો, જવાબો અને મુખ્ય શબ્દો

શું અહીં અભ્યાસ મફત છે?

હા. Nexus Consortium ની આગેવાની હેઠળની Risk Academy નો દરેક અભ્યાસક્રમ અને શિક્ષણ સામગ્રી અભ્યાસ માટે મફત છે, સ્વ-ગતિએ અથવા સમૂહ સાથે. સામાન્ય ભાગીદારી માટે કોઈ ફી નથી; ચૂકવણીવાળું કાર્ય, ઇન્ટર્નશિપ અને ફેલોશિપ અલગ વ્યવસ્થાઓ છે.

અભ્યાસક્રમ પૂર્ણ કરવાથી મને શું મળે છે?

A completion record: the course, its version, the date and what was assessed, private by default and shared by you. It stacks into discipline, department and programme achievements. A record states what was studied and assessed and does not certify competence; it is not a licence, a professional title or an employment status.

ડેટા અને સ્થળો ક્યાંથી આવે છે?

Every faculty teaches on a twin of a real place built from open data; each layer carries its provider, licence and date, and every result on the Academy states its source. Maps and figures are indicators for teaching, never an assessment of a place.

How do I take part beyond the courses in security, defence and hybrid threats?

Form a competence cell of three to seven people, study a shared pathway, take a supervised assignment in the National Working Groups, or bring a cohort from your institution. For organisations.

મુખ્ય શબ્દો

Hybrid threat
Coordinated use of military and non-military means, such as sabotage, cyber attacks and disinformation, below the threshold of open war.
Grey zone
Competition between states that stays below the threshold that would trigger a conventional military response.
Total defence
A national approach in which civil society, business and government prepare alongside the armed forces.
Economic coercion
The use of trade, investment or financial measures to pressure another state.

અહેવાલોયોગદાન આપો

આ પૃષ્ઠ પરથી પુરાવાનું યોગદાન આપો.

Reports is the Consortium's quarterly publication. What you know about this subject can become evidence, a case or a correction in the next edition, credited to you and published under CC BY 4.0 where it is your own work.

Risk Academy

Never send personal data, sensitive infrastructure detail or anything you have no right to share. A contribution is reviewed before use; sending it confers no authorship or editorial rights, and sponsorship never buys a finding.

સુરક્ષા, સંરક્ષણ અને મિશ્ર ખતરા

Prepare with a related course

Open courses in connected disciplines teach the methods this discipline will build on.

અભ્યાસક્રમ સૂચિ જુઓBack to Department of Peace, Conflict and Security