Skip to content

Risk Academy, led by the Nexus Consortium · Systems and Nexus Studies · Department of Systemic Risk and Complexity

Thresholds, early warning signals and the resilience that keeps systems away from them

Kantelpunte en veerkragtigheid van aard- en sosiale stelsels

Tipping points and resilience is the study of thresholds beyond which a system shifts abruptly, and often irreversibly, to another state, and of the properties that keep it from doing so.

Map tipping points and resilience of Earth and social systems on a real placeSee the courses

Illustrative: a state in a double-well potential, tipping and returning with hysteresis as the forcing changes

01Omvang

What the discipline covers

The subtopics its courses and labs teach.

Kursusse
In preparation
Vlakke
In development
Laboratoriums
In development
  • Bifurcations and alternative stable states
  • Climate tipping elements: ice sheets, ocean circulation, tropical forests, coral reefs, permafrost
  • Ecological regime shifts
  • Social and economic tipping points
  • Early warning signals: critical slowing down, variance and autocorrelation
  • Resilience measurement and recovery rates
  • Tipping cascades between elements
  • Positive tipping points in technology and behaviour
  • Governance of tipping risks

02Kaarte

Build a twin of any place

Search any place or open the world; the layers and generators follow tipping points and resilience of Earth and social systems on the planet map, the globe and in 3D.

The Tonle Sap and the Lower Mekong at Phnom Penh: a flat plan of the faculty twin. Terrain 0 to 1,700 m; River 2,956 km; 14 dams; 6 power plants, 88 MW; Tree cover 37.8 percent of the box; Cropland 39.9 percent of the box; Built-up 0.9 percent of the box; Permanent water 4.7 percent of the box; River discharge, GloFAS via Open-Meteo: read live when the 3D twin opens; Vegetation index, MODIS Terra NDVI 8-day: read live when the 3D twin opens; Surface water extent, OPERA DSWx (HLS): the flood pulse: read live when the 3D twin opens; Land cover classes, MODIS IGBP (annual): read live when the 3D twin opens. Contours every 250 metres from the elevation grid; named rivers by class; cropland, tree cover, water and built-up shares (esa worldcover 2021) as the class holding a quarter or more of each cell; dams as marks; power plants as marks.
The Tonle Sap and the Lower Mekong at Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Flat plan of the same data: the lake and rivers, the dams, the plants by capacity, the cropland and tree cover cells and the numbers below. The 3D twin opens on devices that can draw it, once its data and code have been checked; discharge, vegetation, surface water and the annual land cover load in the twin on request, each with its data date.
  • Terrain 0 to 1,700 m
  • River 2,956 km
  • 14 dams
  • 6 power plants, 88 MW
  • Tree cover 37.8 percent of the box
  • Cropland 39.9 percent of the box
  • Built-up 0.9 percent of the box
  • Permanent water 4.7 percent of the box
  • River discharge, GloFAS via Open-Meteo: read live when the 3D twin opens
  • Vegetation index, MODIS Terra NDVI 8-day: read live when the 3D twin opens
  • Surface water extent, OPERA DSWx (HLS): the flood pulse: read live when the 3D twin opens
  • Land cover classes, MODIS IGBP (annual): read live when the 3D twin opens
Credits and dates per layer are listed under the stage. Relief in the twin is exaggerated ×1.5 for legibility.

Drag to move, right drag or Shift with a drag to turn and tilt, Ctrl with the wheel to zoom. Keyboard: arrows move, Shift with arrows turn and tilt, + and – zoom, 0 resets, V steps through the views, Escape clears.

Flat plan of the same data: the lake and rivers, the dams, the plants by capacity, the cropland and tree cover cells and the numbers below. The 3D twin opens on devices that can draw it, once its data and code have been checked; discharge, vegetation, surface water and the annual land cover load in the twin on request, each with its data date.

The boundaries, names and designations shown do not imply any judgement on the legal status of any territory, or any endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. Countries: Natural Earth (public domain).

03The subject

The subject, methods and measures and debates and bodies

The discipline

The field and its scope

For climate and ecosystem analysts, resilience planners and investors who need to recognise approaching thresholds, read early-warning evidence critically and judge what keeps a system away from a transition.

Tipping points and resilience is the study of thresholds beyond which a system shifts abruptly, and often irreversibly, to another state, and of the properties that keep it from doing so. The theory comes from dynamical systems: alternative stable states, bifurcations and hysteresis. The cases come from the Earth system (ice sheets, the Atlantic overturning circulation, the Amazon forest, coral reefs, permafrost), from ecosystems (lakes, drylands, fisheries) and from societies and markets, where norms, technologies and prices can tip too. Its users are climate and ecosystem scientists, resilience planners, financial supervisors and the governance bodies that must act before a threshold is crossed.

The field is organised around three strands. The first is identification: which elements have thresholds, at what forcing, and how they interact in cascades. The second is detection: statistical signatures of critical slowing down, rising variance and autocorrelation that may precede a transition, and their known false positives. The third is resilience: the recovery rate and the latitude a system retains, how to measure it and how to govern for it, including the deliberate use of positive tipping points to speed desirable change. The Global Tipping Points reports of 2023 and 2025 are the current synthesis.

Measures

Quantities and units

QuantityUnit or scaleWhat to know
Tipping thresholddegrees Celsius of global warming above pre-industrial, with a rangeThe forcing at which an element is assessed to tip. Assessed ranges are wide: for the Greenland ice sheet and warm-water coral reefs they begin near or below 1.5 degrees, for the Atlantic overturning circulation estimates span 1.4 to 8 degrees. The central estimate is far less certain than the existence of a threshold.
Lag-1 autocorrelation and variance trenddimensionless; Kendall tau of the rolling statistic against timeThe early-warning indicators of critical slowing down: as a system nears a bifurcation, recovery from perturbation slows, so successive observations resemble each other more and fluctuations grow. Significance is tested against surrogate series; detrending, window length and data gaps change the result and must be reported.
Recovery rateper unit time (inverse of return time to equilibrium after a perturbation)The direct measure of resilience in the engineering sense. It is estimated from observed or experimental perturbations and is reliable only when the perturbation is small enough to stay in the basin of the current state.
Hysteresis widththe forcing unit (for example degrees Celsius or nutrient load)The gap between the forcing at which a system tips and the forcing at which it recovers. A wide hysteresis means a transition is effectively irreversible on human timescales; it is known from models and palaeo-records and is rarely observed directly.
Committed and realised timescale of transitionyears to centuriesThe time between crossing a threshold and the completion of the shift. Ice sheets take centuries to millennia, coral reefs and lakes years to decades. Policy relevance depends as much on this timescale as on the threshold.

Metodes

Methods and their limits

Each method is listed with what it assumes and where it fails.

MetodeAssumesFails when
Bifurcation analysis of conceptual and process modelsThe system can be reduced to a low-dimensional model whose equilibria can be traced as a control parameter varies, revealing folds, hysteresis and alternative states.High-dimensional systems may have no clean bifurcation structure; noise-induced and rate-induced tipping occur without any bifurcation; and the reduced model's threshold need not match the full system's.
Early-warning signal detection (critical slowing down)The approaching transition is a bifurcation, the system is forced slowly relative to its internal dynamics, and the observed series is long, evenly sampled and stationary apart from the approach.Changes in noise or in observation method mimic the signal; some transitions give no warning; and detection has low power at the lead times decision makers need, so an indicator is evidence to weigh rather than a trigger on its own.
Palaeoclimate and palaeoecological reconstructionPast abrupt transitions recorded in ice cores, sediments and corals constrain the thresholds, speeds and hysteresis of the same elements today.Past boundary conditions differ from present forcing rates; proxy dating uncertainty blurs sequence and cause; and the record contains few analogues for the current rate of change.
Earth-system model experimentsCoupled models with resolved ice, ocean, vegetation and permafrost processes can reproduce thresholds and interactions under specified forcing.Many models still lack interactive ice sheets or permafrost carbon, model thresholds differ widely, and the ensemble spread is a lower bound on uncertainty because models share structure.
Network models of interacting tipping elementsElements can be represented as coupled nodes with directed interactions of known sign and approximate strength, so that cascades can be sampled under uncertainty.Interaction strengths are largely elicited; the models are conceptual and omit timescales and spatial pattern; results are a sensitivity study of the elicited links rather than a prediction.

Debates

What the field debates

Are early-warning signals reliable enough to act on?
Proponents cite laboratory, lake and model demonstrations in which autocorrelation and variance rose before a transition, and observational studies reporting such trends for the Atlantic overturning circulation and the Amazon. Sceptics cite transitions that showed no warning, warnings not followed by transitions, and sensitivity to pre-processing; they argue the indicators should inform but not trigger decisions. Both sides agree on the need for surrogate testing and for stating the assumed transition type.
Is the planetary-boundary framing scientifically sound?
Its authors present nine Earth-system processes with quantified thresholds defining a safe operating space, updated in 2023 with six assessed as transgressed. Critics argue that for several processes, biodiversity in particular, no global threshold exists in the evidence and that the framing turns regional, gradual change into a single global number that can mislead policy. The disagreement is partly about whether a boundary must be a tipping point or may be a precautionary limit.
Positive tipping points: real leverage or re-badged diffusion?
Advocates argue that self-reinforcing adoption in solar power, electric vehicles and some social norms shows that small interventions can trigger disproportionate change, and that cost-parity thresholds are now observable. Critics argue that these are standard technology-diffusion curves with no bifurcation and that calling them tipping points borrows authority from Earth-system science. Evidence from price and adoption series is used by both sides.

Bodies and data

Bodies that set practice, and the data they publish

Bodies and standards are named so learners can find and apply their published work; the Academy teaches their use and links to the publisher, and no affiliation is implied.

BodyRole in the field
Global Systems Institute, University of ExeterLeads the Global Tipping Points reports (2023 and 2025), broad syntheses of Earth-system, ecological and positive tipping evidence.
Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK)Home of the original tipping-elements assessment and of the network models of interacting tipping elements.
Stockholm Resilience CentreDeveloped the resilience and planetary-boundary frameworks and maintains the Regime Shifts Database of documented ecological transitions.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)Its assessment reports grade the evidence and likelihood of abrupt changes and tipping elements that governments use in negotiation.
RAPID-MOC programmeOperates the moored array at 26 degrees North that has monitored the Atlantic overturning circulation continuously since 2004, the key observational series in the tipping debate.
DatasetSteward
RAPID 26N Atlantic overturning transport time seriesNational Oceanography Centre and partners
Regime Shifts DatabaseStockholm Resilience Centre
Sea Ice IndexNational Snow and Ice Data Center
Global Tipping Points ReportGlobal Systems Institute, University of Exeter

04Die metode

Slowing down before the fold: how a recovery rate becomes an early warning signal

As a forcing approaches a tipping threshold the system recovers from small knocks ever more slowly; that slowing shows up as rising autocorrelation and variance in a long record, and the trend in those statistics, not any single value, is what an early warning signal reads.

Sources: Scheffer et al., Early-warning signals for critical transitions (2009); Dakos et al., Slowing down as an early warning signal for abrupt climate change (2008); Armstrong McKay et al., Exceeding 1.5°C global warming could trigger multiple climate tipping points (2022); Boers, Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (2021).

05At a glance

At a glance, hub and courses

3D-grafiek

Fakulteit vir Stelsel- en Nexus-studies

211 nodes1,557 relations9 views

Explore the 3D graph: Faculty of Systems and Nexus Studies

06Konsole

How Tipping points and resilience of Earth and social systems is taught, as a process you can run

Press Play to run this process from this page’s own data.

Kantelpunte en veerkragtigheid van aard- en sosiale stelsels

How Tipping points and resilience of Earth and social systems is taught

5 subjects in scope, 3 key terms, courses in development, 1 lab, in the Systemic Risk and Complexity department of Systems and Nexus Studies: from the scope to the method and its terms, the courses that teach it, the labs on the twin, the assessment and the record.

  1. 01 Scope

    1. 01

      Bifurcations and alternative stable states

      Start · the discipline

      Bifurcations and alternative stable states

    2. 02

      Climate tipping elements: ice sheets, ocean circulation

      Start · the discipline

      Climate tipping elements: ice sheets, ocean circulation, tropical forests, coral reefs, permafrost

    3. 03

      Ecological regime shifts

      Start · the discipline

      Ecological regime shifts

    4. 04

      Social and economic tipping points

      Start · the discipline

      Social and economic tipping points

    5. 05

      Early warning signals: critical slowing down, variance

      Start · the discipline

      Early warning signals: critical slowing down, variance and autocorrelation

  2. 02 Method and terms

    1. 06

      Slowing down before the fold: how

      Model · the learner

      As a forcing approaches a tipping threshold the system recovers from small knocks ever more slowly.

    2. 07

      Tipping point

      Record · the discipline

      A critical threshold at which a small change pushes a system into a qualitatively different state.

    3. 09

      Critical slowing down

      Record · the discipline

      The slower recovery from small perturbations as a system approaches a tipping point.

    4. 11

      Hysteresis

      Record · the discipline

      The property that a system does not return to its earlier state when the driver is reversed.

  3. 04 Labs

    1. 08

      Tweeling

      Exercise · the learner, on the faculty twin

      The method runs on the faculty twin and the admitted map layers.

  4. 05 Assess

    1. 10

      Module checks

      Gate · the course

      Each module ends with a short check against its outcomes.

    2. 12

      Assessed work

      Decision · the learner

      The assessed work that closes a course: a lab record, a case memo or an assignment, reviewed against the rubric.

  5. 06 Record

    1. 13

      Voltooiingsrekord

      Outcome · the learner

      The record stacks into the discipline achievement.

    2. 14

      Discipline achievement

      Record · the Academy

      The discipline achievement follows the discipline rule, read from the records.

Tipping points and resilience of Earth and social systems · Systemic Risk and Complexity An outline of how the work is designed to run; it does not report the status of any decision or record.

07Leer

Achievements, where this is practised, practised in and across the ecosystem

Prestasies

Achievements in this discipline

  1. Course achievements

    One for each course with this as its primary discipline, earned when you pass the course’s assessed activities.

  2. Department: Systemic Risk and Complexity

    Earn two discipline achievements in the Department of Systemic Risk and Complexity. In development.

An achievement is a record of the learning completed and assessed here. How recognition works.

Where this is practised

Where the subject is practised

A field platform page on this subject is in development.

Practised in

The two Foundry systems where it is practised

Foundry system pages describe what each system and its rooms are designed to do; the courses teach the methods these systems apply.

Across the ecosystem

Across the ecosystem

The science, platforms and standards this discipline draws on and contributes to across the ecosystem.

Foundations in the STEM Commons

  • The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI Canada)Complex systems and agent-based modellingComplex systems and agent-based modelling study systems whose behaviour emerges from interactions among many components.
  • Climate and atmospheric scienceClimate science studies the physical processes that govern the atmosphere, oceans, cryosphere and land surface over seasons to centuries.
  • Ecology and biodiversity scienceEcology studies the interactions among organisms and between organisms and their environment, from populations to ecosystems.

Pages of the ecosystem, cited so learners can follow the field into research, platforms, standards and national practice.

08Neem deel

Take part in Systems and Nexus Studies

Begin by wie u is.

Roetes

  • Roete

    Nasionale instellings

    Ministeries, statistiekkantore en agentskappe: 'n nasionale lessenaar en tak, en 'n setel in die werkgroepe. Nasionale hoofstukke

  • Roete

    Sektore en beroepe

    Operators, regulators, banks, insurers and professional bodies whose work touches systems and nexus studies. For organisations

  • Roete

    Leer

    Kursusse en praktyk, met 'n rekord van elke voltooide kursus. Gratis om te studeer. Oop leer

  • Roete

    Standaarde

    Stel die metodes en datastandaarde saam met die werkgroepe op, hersien en aanvaar dit. Werkgroepe

  • Roete

    Gemeenskappe en navorsing

    Universities, civil society and individual experts: projects, data and review. Write to the Academy

Oop oproepe

Oop oproepSoekSluit
Stigtingsoproep vir kundiges vir die werkgroepe CALL-FOUNDING-EXPERTSkundige, redakteur, voorsitter2026-12-15
Oop nominasie vir die drie onafhanklike kundigesetels van die Wêreldwye Standaarderaad CALL-GSC-INDraadslid2026-12-01
Nominasies van tussentydse streekslede (geld slegs as daar oor die oorgangsbepaling besluit word) CALL-GSC-REGraadslid2026-12-15
Hersiening van die uiteensettings van die golf-1-risikokern (C1, C2, C3, C4, C8, C10, C11) CALL-REVIEW-WAVE1bydraer2027-01-31
Kundiges vir die kernstandaarde van risikowetenskap: onsekerheid en gradering van bewyse, skale, gestruktureerde kundige oordeel, aanvaarbaarheid, uiterstes en saamgestelde gebeure, katastrofiese en eksistensiële risiko, etiek en billikheid, eenhede en meting (NRS-C17 tot NRS-C24) CALL-CORE-SCIENCEkundige, redakteur, voorsitter2027-01-31
Onafhanklike beoordelaars vir die families van die gevaar-atlas, drie uit minstens twee streke vir elke familie (NHS2-R19), prioriteitsfamilies eerste CALL-ATLAS-REVIEWkundige2027-03-31
Lede van die tussentydse Frontier Safety Review Panel en rooispanbeoordelaars (biologiese veiligheid en biosekuriteit, KI-veiligheid en -sekuriteit, sekuriteit van kritieke infrastruktuur); aansoeke word vertroulik hanteer CALL-FRONTIER-SAFETY-REVIEWkundige2026-11-30
Kundiges in ontologie, metrologie, sagtewareverifikasie en konformiteitsbeoordeling vir die vereisteregister, die NHS-2-masjienvoorstelling, die konformiteitstoetsreekse en die konformiteitsbeoordelingskema CALL-CONFORMANCE-ONTOLOGYkundige, redakteur2027-01-31

Oproepe ná hul sluitingsdatum word outomaties versteek. Elke oproep, voorstel en roete: oop gebiede en oproepe.

Selle en CERT's

  1. Bring die sel bymekaar

    Bring drie tot sewe mense met aanvullende vaardighede bymekaar: data, veldpraktyk, beleid en kommunikasie.

  2. Registreer dit

    Write to the team with the cell's name, members, area and region. You receive a reference and a contact. Write to the Academy

  3. Kies 'n handves

    Kies een fokus: navorsing en bewyse, data en kaarte, hersiening van standaarde, of gemeenskapsgereedheid.

  4. Leer saam

    Volg gedeelde studiepaaie by Risk Academy, met praktyk en 'n rekord van elke voltooide kursus. Gevare en veerkragtigheid

  5. Lei en rapporteer

    Hold regular sessions. Publish what the cell learns through Reports. Bring findings to the working groups. Working groups

  • Spesialiseer as 'n Gemeenskapsnoodreaksiespan (CERT)

    A CERT prepares its neighbourhood for the hazards it faces. It builds a local hazard profile from this site's map. It trains in household and street preparedness. It learns first aid and light search through recognised local providers, and it runs drills. A CERT works alongside the local emergency services and follows their direction. It never replaces them and is not an emergency service.

Die Indeks

Wat 'n nasionale span of 'n plaaslike gemeenskap vandag op The Global Risks Index (NXS-GRX) kan doen.

  • NXS-GRX

    Your country's profile

    Oop risikoprofiele vir 195 lande, met bronne en lisensies by elke waarde. Open die Indeks

  • NXS-GRX

    Korrigeer of antwoord

    Korrigeer 'n waarde of antwoord namens jou land. Die verandering word met sy effek aangeteken. Open die Indeks

  • NXS-GRX

    Bied data aan

    Bied 'n datastel aan. Dit kom deur die lisensiehek in, met erkenning aan jou. Open die Indeks

  • NXS-GRX

    Gebruik die oop data

    Lae, profiele en teëls deur die oop API. Open die Indeks

09References

Core references and where to begin

Start with Scheffer, then Lenton, then Scheffer.

  1. Lenton, T. M. et al., Tipping elements in the Earth's climate system (2008). DOI
  2. Scheffer, M., Carpenter, S., Foley, J. A., Folke, C. and Walker, B., Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems (2001). DOI
  3. Scheffer, M. et al., Early-warning signals for critical transitions (2009). DOI
  4. Dakos, V. et al., Slowing down as an early warning signal for abrupt climate change (2008). DOI
  5. Armstrong McKay, D. I. et al., Exceeding 1.5°C global warming could trigger multiple climate tipping points (2022). DOI
  6. Wunderling, N., Donges, J. F., Kurths, J. and Winkelmann, R., Interacting tipping elements increase risk of climate domino effects under global warming (2021). DOI
  7. Boers, N., Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (2021). DOI
  8. Holling, C. S., Resilience and stability of ecological systems (1973). DOI
  9. Walker, B., Holling, C. S., Carpenter, S. R. and Kinzig, A., Resilience, adaptability and transformability in social-ecological systems (2004). DOI
  10. Lenton, T. M. et al., Operationalising positive tipping points towards global sustainability (2022). DOI
  11. Richardson, K. et al., Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries (2023). DOI
  12. Montoya, J. M., Donohue, I. and Pimm, S. L., Planetary boundaries for biodiversity: implausible science, pernicious policies (2018). DOI

10Vrae

Vrae, antwoorde en kernterme

Is studie hier gratis?

Ja. Elke kursus en leermateriaal van Risk Academy, gelei deur die Nexus Consortium, is gratis om te studeer, op eie tempo of saam met 'n groep. Gewone deelname het geen fooi nie; betaalde werk, internskappe en genootskappe is afsonderlike reëlings.

Wat gee die voltooiing van 'n kursus my?

'n Voltooiingsrekord: die kursus, sy weergawe, die datum en wat geassesseer is, by verstek privaat en deur u gedeel. Dit stapel op tot dissipline-, departements- en programprestasies. 'n Rekord meld wat bestudeer en geassesseer is en sertifiseer nie bevoegdheid nie; dit is nie 'n lisensie, 'n professionele titel of 'n indiensnemingstatus nie.

Waar kom die data en die plekke vandaan?

Elke fakulteit onderrig op 'n tweeling van 'n werklike plek wat uit oop data gebou is; elke laag dra sy verskaffer, lisensie en datum, en elke resultaat op die Akademie vermeld sy bron. Kaarte en figure is aanwysers vir onderrig, nooit 'n assessering van 'n plek nie.

How do I take part beyond the courses in tipping points and resilience of Earth and social systems?

Vorm 'n bevoegdheidsel van drie tot sewe mense, bestudeer 'n gedeelde roete, neem 'n opdrag onder toesig in die Nasionale Werkgroepe, of bring 'n groep van jou instelling. Vir organisasies.

Kernterme

Tipping point
A critical threshold at which a small change pushes a system into a qualitatively different state.
Critical slowing down
The slower recovery from small perturbations as a system approaches a tipping point.
Hysteresis
The property that a system does not return to its earlier state when the driver is reversed.
Tipping element
A large component of the Earth system that may pass a tipping point, such as an ice sheet or the Amazon forest.

VerslaeDra by

Dra bewyse vanaf hierdie bladsy by.

Reports is the Consortium’s quarterly publication. What you know about this subject can become evidence, a case or a correction in the next edition, credited to you and published under CC BY 4.0 where it is your own work.

Risk Academy

Stuur nooit persoonlike data, sensitiewe infrastruktuurbesonderhede of enigiets wat u geen reg het om te deel nie. 'n Bydrae word voor gebruik beoordeel; die stuur daarvan verleen geen outeurskap of redaksionele regte nie, en borgskap koop nooit 'n bevinding nie.

Kantelpunte en veerkragtigheid van aard- en sosiale stelsels

Prepare with a related course

Open courses in connected disciplines teach the methods this discipline will build on.

Blaai deur die kursuskatalogusBack to Department of Systemic Risk and Complexity